I remember talking to Robin Grille about it all. I almost fell over backwards when he said he didn't like the whole attachment parenting thing. At the time I thought that attachment parenting was da bomb you see. But Robin had seen a different side of it. One that I am only just starting to see with regularity now. Parental burnout.
I know so many mummas trying to parent their children a la The Continuum Concept while living in our separatist, perfectionist society. Most of us live on our own with our nuclear families where one parent is solely responsible for the children. Being at home all day with hugely dependant children while trying to break old cycles and not crush their poor little souls is virtually impossible. And we are setting ourselves up to fail.
I have had to find my way with this parenting gig. I read a line in a Dr Sears book once that changed my life. I think it was in the Baby Sleep Book and it said something like - if you don't like something (are really, deeply not happy about something) then something has to change. This was when I was breastfeeding Jake (he was just over 2) and pregnant with Aron. Jake was feeding a million times a night and I was in pain with every feed. So I night weaned him. It wasn't the most pleasant thing I have ever done but he did cope so much better than I ever thought he would. And I think we both learnt a very valuable lesson. That I have needs that are important too and that it is ok to be sad/angry/pissed off. He also learnt that he could be and show all of those emotions and I would still be there and still love him.

As my children get older, the negotiations and compromise become more even. We have rules and boundaries that are really very solid. Most of them are around safety but lots are around personal space and respect. I try very hard to communicate these boundaries clearly so there are no misunderstandings and then to enforce them when they are challenged. And sometimes this involves quite a bit of unpleasantness. I yell, hell sometimes I scream. I get angry. Quite a lot actually. But I think it is important for children to see (age appropriate) anger. I would much prefer my children to see clear anger from me when I feel it rather than an insidious build up of resentment that poisons every interaction we have (often leading to a hugely inappropriate explosion of rage).
I really think it is important for children to see all sorts of emotions. I hear some parents speak to their children in such a boring, almost pleading monotone, "oh sweetie, please don't do that, darling, we don't do that....." or "no sweetie, we don't run across the road because we could get hit by a car because cars go so very fast and the people driving them don't expect people to just run out onto the road, I know it looks like fun and that you want to run on the road but it really is dangerous sweetie...blah....blah...blah...." jeebus, if I were a kid I would run onto the road just to get away from it.

I think it is important to respect children, which involves talking to them like they are human, not a chiuaua.

This is all part of the reason why I don't feel like I fit in with the "crunchier" crowd. Sometimes I think they have a competition going to see who can hold their baby the most, who can breastfeed the longest, who can delay solids the longest, who can have the least amount of rules (and still be zen). What they forget to do is to look at their child and their family and their individual circumstances.
I've been there. Putting the ideals above my own needs, above the needs of the family. I still struggle with it, finding the happy median is one of the hardest things about being a parent.
I find the attachment parenting principles really sound but I do prioritise. I call myself an attachment parent because I follow what I believe are the most important practices. I co-sleep, breastfeed full term, I believe that vaccinations are harmful and that schooling is damaging. I believe that children should be treated with respect and kindness. I believe elimination communication is ideal, and failing that, cloth nappies should be used. I think that hammocks and dummies are poor replacements for human arms and breasts. I believe in baby led weaning and the thought of spoon feeding makes my stomach churn, I also believe that the longer a baby is EXCLUSIVELY breastfed the better. I don't think punishment and rewards work and I believe in unschooling. However.....
I haven't been coping really well these past few months so I have started using disposable nappies, using a dummy and/or the hammock (and other peoples arms!) when I have needed to. I have introduced some more structure in the form of a curriculum and some (light?) punishment and rewards in the form of pocket money and clear consequences.
I weaned both my boys at night and encouraged the full weaning process when it started with both of them (Jake was 3 and a half and Aron was 2 and 8 months). And maybe all of this means that I'm not really "AP" enough. But you know what? I've let go of it. I've found it easier to let go of it all this time round and I think that's because it is working. For all of us! How nice....




